Historical Research in the Modern Library
Originally developed for a class in the Society for Creative
Anachronism, by Pani
Jadwiga Zajaczkowa , Jennifer
Heise
"In
early days,
I tried not to give librarians any trouble, which
was where I made my
primary mistake. Librarians like to be given
trouble; they exist for
it, they are geared to it. For the location of a
mislaid volume, an
uncatalogued item, your good librarian has a
ferret’s nose. Give her a
scent and she jumps
the leash, her eye bright with battle."
Catherine
Drinker Bowen (1897–1973), U.S.
biographer. Adventures of a Biographer, ch. 9
(1959). |
About
Libraries * Reference
* Serials/Periodicals
* Special
Collections/Rare Books * Dissertations
and Theses * Microforms
* Electronic
Collections * Photocopying
* ILL:
What to do if the Library doesn't have the item you want *
Classification
Systems * Reference
Books * Finding
Tools * Techniques
of Searching * Types
of Sources * Copyright
& Plagiarism * Internet
Use * Citing
What you Find * Other
sites
to check out
The first thing to do before beginning your research is to have
a game plan. That means thinking about what you want to find out,
then
thinking about where you are likely to find it.
For instance, are you interested in historical events? Or is there
an
object you want to research? Or are are you interested in
researching a
particular culture? If you are doing object oriented research, are
you
interested primarily in how to make one in the modern world, the
appearance of the period object, the construction of the period
object,
or all three? How much information do you already have? If you are
just
starting out on A&S research, persona research, or learning a
craft
or activity, you may be looking for more generalized material; if
you
have mastered the
basics of something and want period references and depictions to
work
from,
you will be looking in different areas.
About Libraries
Different libraries have different types of collections, so you
will
want to plan your research and finding efforts based on the
materials
you are looking for. Also, different libraries offer different
types of
services, so that is a factor too.
Types of libraries:
What resources and what kind of help you can get often depends on
what
libraries you visit. It's often useful to start with the libraries
that are most beholden to you, either because you are affiliated
with
them
or they get public funding. Even if the librarians cannot answer
your
question there, they can sometimes refer you to other libraries that
can
help.
Before visiting a library, call (or email) to check out what access
to
the collections you may have. Certain private university and special
libraries don't allow the public in, or require special ID or
references,
or limit times and collections that are available to the public.
Some
libraries
will issue you a library card (for free or for a fee) to check out
books
even if you are not part of their primary clientele; others won't.
Many libraries allow anyone visiting in person to use their
resources; some have public computers for this purpose. You may also
want to see if they have public WiFi, so you can bring a laptop or
tablet and access resources that way.
Most libraries have their catalogs available to the general public
and
searchable over the web-- check to see if the library has a
web
site and look for their catalog there. Checking the catalog before
visiting the library can save you a lot of time!
In addition to looking up "Libraries in [place name]" on Google, try
these directories.
- Public (locally supported; open access; basic
materials-- go to district or county libraries for more depth.)
- State libraries or library divisions (open to anyone
in
the state; materials vary, often strongest in educational
materials.
State libraries often coordinate state-wide online database
access
programs.)
- Public universities (state supported; often open
access;
collections more scholarly)
- Private universities (tuiton-supported; access may be
limited; scholarly collections, in-depth but often narrow)
- Special libraries in companies and museums (supported
by
institutions or donations; access limited; narrow collections of
varying depth)
The American Library Association Directory will help you
find information about libraries in a given geographic area. Most
libraries have a copy.
Just for fun, check out The European Library, which allows
searching the National Libraries of 30+
European countries: http://www.theeuropeanlibrary.org/tel4/
Many museums have library collections that may be open
to the
public. Call
the museum or check out their web site to see what services are
available. You may need a letter of recommendation or
introduction-- if
your local library is familiar with you, that's the first place to
go
for one of those.
Check with your local librarian for more cues about libraries to
visit.
Reference:
Reference librarians will help you use the finding tools and get
the information you need. Also, the 'reference collection' holds
information finding tools and 'reference works' (collections of
facts and data for quick look-ups). Most new reference works are
online, but older ones are still in book form. Reference books
generally don't circulate, i.e., they can't be checked out of the
library.
Reference librarians at your library can often be reached by phone,
email, or even online chat: check out your library's web
site to find out. The Library of Congress has a page for its chat
and email services, at:
http://www.loc.gov/rr/askalib/
Some reference works are available online through www.bartleby.com.
The best way to get help and make the best use of a library's
resources is to inquire at the reference desk! Reference
librarians try to keep track of useful sources for research, in
the library or on the internet.
Librarian Marylaine Block says: "Even
when
we've found exactly what our user wanted, many of us will keep
on
looking, keep on playing because we became more curious about
the topic
than our user did. Knowledge is a lot like a ball of yarn, and
what we
all do is tug
at the end and pull it out, a little at a time, until we have
just as
much
as our user needs. But we also know that every bit of
information
we find gives us more clues, and that we could keep tugging and
tugging
until the whole ball lies in a little puddle of yarn on the
floor."
Collections
Serials or Periodicals
The terms 'serials' or 'periodicals' collections are used to refer
to a
library's collection of magazines and journal subscriptions. Most
libraries, especially academic ones, have 'electronic
journal' subscriptions as part of their collection: articles from
certain journal issues/volumes are accessed through the Web; access
to electronic journals is usually restricted to the campus or
current users, and printing may be
restricted or involve a fee.
Current issues of print journals are usually shelved separately;
older ones are bound or on
microfilm.
Some general history magazines, such as History Today, Archaeology
Today, Smithsonian, Discovering Archaeology,
may be
worth simply sitting down and scanning through.
Most ejournal vendor platforms, such as Jstor and Science Direct,
will let you search the tables of contents of multiple
magazines/journals, but you'll need a subscription or to pay by
use to access most contents. Google Scholar
(http://scholar.google.com) searches across these vendor websites
as well as repositories where free copies may be posted. To
find periodical articles on particular subjects, try using an
appropriate index.
Some journals and magazines are available free on the web: see
the Directory of Open Access Journals: http://www.doaj.org/
for examples.
'Circulating Collection' aka 'General Collection'
Library collections which can be checked out. Most can be searched
using the catalog. Mainly books or 'monographs'; may include
pamphlets,
CD's, records, tapes, videotapes, CD-ROM, movies, and/or real
objects
along with books. (Monographs are one-off rather than 'serial' or
repeating publications: sometimes monographs/books are published as
part of series, and
if you happen on the title of a relevant series, you can find other
useful
items in the series.) Generally circulating collections are in open
stacks, where you can browse the shelves and retrieve the
items
yourself; older
books are sometimes in closed stacks and you may need to
request
that they be retrieved for you.
Special
Collections, Rare Books
Some libraries have collections of rare books and/or specific
subject collections. You will want to call ahead before
visiting special collections: they often have limited hours or
hours by arrangement. There is a book (Subject collections : a
guide to special book collections and subject emphases as
reported by university, college, public, and special libraries
and museums in the United States and Canada, by Lee Ash and
William G. Miller), that lists some of them, and the American
Library Directory will also tell you what special
collections a library has. An online source that lists special
collections departments is Repositories of Primary Sources
http://www.uidaho.edu/special-collections/Other.Repositories.html.
You may need to contact the special collections librarian to make
an appointment to see the collections-- they are usually in closed
stacks. Leave pens, ink, food and drink, and anything else
that
might damage a book in the car when you go to visit special
collections.
Government documents/document depository:
Many large local libraries and college libraries are U.S. Government
'depository' libraries, which means that they get some US Government
publications for free in exchange for providing access and help with
them to the public. How-to publications and materials from the
Library of Congress are items that may be available as government
documents. A private university library which is also a depository
library is may be more open to the public than a non-depository.
Electronic
collections, E-books, E-journals
Libraries buy access via the web, or on CD-ROM or other computer
file, to finding tools such as indexes, as well as books, journals
and collections of texts. Access to electronic resources may be
restricted. Depository libraries get access to government documents
'on-line', as well. Most libraries catalog these resources, and many
catalog free internet resources. Reference librarians can be a help
with searching the Internet, also.
Many states and consortia have started online cooperative electronic
collections: ask at your local and/or state library about this. In
many cases, you will be able to access these resources from home by
a link from your libraries' website (and providing your Library card
number or other identification). Check with your local and state
libraries to find out if any of these are available to you.
Microforms
Older journals and reproductions of rare books are often found on
microfilm (long rolls) or microfiche (cards). These may be listed
individually in the library catalog, or may be a separate collection
with its own index. Special reader equipment is required to view the
microforms; many libraries have microform reader/printers that will
allow you to print off copies of the pages for a fee.
Photocopying & Printing
Most libraries have photocopiers, as well as printers, on site. Some
take coins or bills, others require special 'copy cards.' Some
microfilm readers also allow printing from the microfilm. Some
libraries charge for printing from their computers (or certain
resources on their computers).
In many cases, libraries will have self-service flatbed scanners or
scanning via their photocopier. If you think you might want to scan
something, it's a good idea to bring a USB 'keychain' drive to store
your scans, though you may be able to save to a Google Drive or send
to an email.
You may want to call or email ahead to check prices for
copying/printing and scanning availability.
Interlibrary
loan (ILL)-- What to do if the book you want isn't in your
library
Most libraries can borrow books or copies of magazine and journal
articles from other libraries, either in the public or university
library system or from libraries throughout the world. You need to
supply a full citation for the material, including a Library of
Congress number or ISBN number if you can; there may be a
charge. Look up information for books via Worldcat
(worldcat.org) or online library catalog services.
Generally, ILL can only be obtained through your local library, but
district and academic libraries sometimes do ILL for people in their
area. Be nice to ILL staff!
Futhermore, many library systems have what's called 'reciprocal
borrowing agreements.' What that means is that if you have a valid
library card with one library in the system, you can borrow books
from other libraries in the system. For instance, Pennsylvania
and some other states have statewide public library reciprocal
borrowing agreements, which allow you to borrow books from other
public libraries in the state with a properly identified library
card from your home library. Ask your library about reciprocal
borrowing agreements with other libraries, and possible 'union
catalogs' that would help you search multiple libraries' catalogs at
one time.
Many libraries will not loan complete issues or bound volumes of
journals. Use an index or check the Internet for the journal's
online presence to find specific articles to request; such
services usually include a sales (document delivery) component,
where you can try to buy a copy of the article if your library
can't get it for you.
The major Interlibrary Loan System, OCLC, has 2 forms of its
'union catalog'-- the free Worldcat.org which includes mostly
larger libraries, and a subscription Worldcat that your ILL staff
will search. Also, reciprocal borrowing systems often have union
catalogs (for instance, AccessPA in Pennsylvania). If you ask
nicely, the librarian or ILL staff may be able to do a subject
search for you or allow you to do a search yourself.
Be aware that rare books, reference books, and fragile volumes
usually cannot be Interlibrary Loaned, and your chances of getting
something through ILL are better if your library is a college or
university library, or the lending library is within a library
cooperative or library system with yours. Interlibrary loans,
especially for books, may take time; your library may be able to
tell you a minimum time period to expect to wait, but from 1-2
weeks up to several months may be necessary. With new scanning and
internet-based document transfer, ILLs of articles generally
arrive much more quickly. Interlibrary loans generally do
cost the borrowing library a fee; you may be asked to pay all or
part of that fee.
If your local library will not attempt to do an interlibrary loan
for you (this is rare but it happens) check with your state
library about other libraries that may be able to help you. It's
uncommon for university libraries to offer interlibrary loan
privileges to non-affiliated users; but it's worth asking, if the
library grants cards to non-affiliated users. In many cases, there
is a 'reciprocal borrowing' system in place that will let you
borrow a book from another library directly-- again, your state
library can help you with those sorts of questions if your public
library is uninformed.
Classification system
& Browsing
There are three major classification systems used in libraries:
Dewey Decimal (numbers 000-999, with each 100 being a subject group,
each 10 being a subject-- look under "Dewey Summaries" on http://www.oclc.org/dewey/resources/summaries/
); LC, Library of Congress (1 and 2 letter alphabetic codes,
followed by numbers-- see http://www.loc.gov/catdir/cpso/lcco/
); and SuDocs, for government documents, where each alphabetic
prefix is a different government division. Most public libraries use
Dewey; most academic libraries use LC. (There is a modified Dewey
system in use in theological libraries, and European libraries use a
different one entirely.) Manuscripts and special collections items
usually are listed by local system numbers, often organized by date
of acquisition or characteristics of the donor/former owner.
Browsing can be a helpful way to find additional resources your
library catalog search didn't turn up, but it's unwise to rely
entirely on browsing, as books can easily be shelved in more than
one call number, and books that are checked out, stored in a special
collection, or 'in storage' won't be visible. Library catalogs often
allow you to browse for other books in the same call number before
even visiting the shelfves
Reference Works
'Reference works' are items that are generally used to look
something up, rather than read or browsed through. Examples include
encyclopedias, dictionaries, atlases, name books and timelines. In
libraries, the books in the reference collection are usually shelved
separately and cannot be checked out of the library. Several
collections of reference books on the web (warning: these are
generally older editions or less popular works) The most accessible
is Bartleby: www.bartleby.com
Librarians tend to create guides on the web for online and print
resources in a particular topic-- the most popular tool for this is
'LibGuides' so a web search for "Libguides [Topic]" can often find
you pages of useful pointers.
Encyclopedias: collections of information on a
wide variety of topics. There are general encyclopedias-- for
example, the Encyclopedia Britannica , which
includes large essays on many historical topics-- and
encyclopedias on specific topics, such as the Dictionary of
the Middle Ages. (You can't always tell what kind of
resource it is by the title!)
General encyclopedias that are available online include the
Columbia Encyclopedia (through www.bartleby.com). You may have
access to the Encyclopedia Britannica online through your local
library's online subscription, and there's a small Encyclopedia,
which appeared in print as the Merriam Webster Collegiate
Encyclopedia , online as the Concise
Encyclopedia Britannica at: http://education.yahoo.com/reference/encyclopedia/
Atlases: books of maps. There are a number of
historical atlases or country atlases. Often an atlas will give a
succinct account of history, not just geography. I like
McEvedy's New Penguin Atlas of Medieval History
but there are many other good ones. Look for historical
atlases of a country or subject, as well.
Dictionaries : Not only are there dictionaries
of different languages (look in the 400's in a Dewey system), but
there are specific dictionaries and glossaries for subjects, some
of which will be in reference, some of which circulate. Web based
dictionaries are also often available. For etymology of English
words back to pre-1600 times, try the Oxford English
Dictionary. Some libraries also have the Middle
English Dictionary, and parts of this work are available
free online at http://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/med/.
A site that has links to many online free dictionaries, including
Old English dictionaries, is Lexilogos-- try
https://www.lexilogos.com/english/english_old.htm
Names books: Many dictionaries of names and
genealogical information are kept in reference; some libraries
have specific genealogical sections where this material lives.
929.4 in Dewey libraries.
... on File : this isn't specifically a type of
reference work. The publisher Facts on File puts out a line of
'... on File' books that are looseleaf collections of reproducible
images, including maps; they also put out timeline books and other
basic reference works.
Timelines : Timeline tools are charts with
annotations that help you compare events, people, or things in
chronological order. Timelines of World History , put
out by DK Publishing, is an example that many libraries have.
Metropolitan Museum's Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History https://www.metmuseum.org/toah/
and Hyperhistory Online http://www.hyperhistory.com/online_n2/History_n2/a.html
are online examples of these kinds of tools. Other online
resources include the Food History Timeline: http://www.foodtimeline.org/
Such timelines are by definition rough-- follow up on other
sources to confirm their claims.
PhD.
Dissertations and Master's Theses:
These documents, written to fulfill the
requirements for a PhD (Doctoral) or Master's degree program, are
not commercially published. Each academic library will have a
collection of Doctoral Dissertations and Master's Theses written
at its institution; it may also have copies of a few dissertations
and theses from other schools in its circulating collection.
However, in some cases, no copy of the dissertation or thesis may
have been deposited with the library, so no copy is
available at all!
Fortunately, theses are now submitted online and most institutions
have 'repositories' where online copies can often be obtained for
free.
- Getting Master's
Theses:
Sometimes these can be borrowed through Interlibrary Loan; this
is worth a try. Your other option is to contact the library of
the college/university and see if you can pay them to make a
copy for you.
- Getting Doctoral Dissertations:
PhD Dissertations, at least American ones, are a lot easier to
get a copy of in most cases. This is because University
Microfilms International has most of them on microfilm/online
and will supply copies for a price. UMI also puts out an index,
called Dissertation and Theses, that lists dissertations by
subject, author, title, school, etc. You can even search the
online version by subject, if the library you are using has a
subscription to the database.
To order a dissertation, go to "Dissertation Express" on the
Proquest.com site http://www.proquest.com/products_umi/dissertations/disexpress.shtml
You can then search by author or title, and select items to
order with a credit card. (If your library has a subscription,
you may be able to see a 24-page preview.)
Finding Tools
Indexes
Most index services include subject keywords assigned to the
journal, magazine, and/or book descriptions by human indexers, in
addition to the machine-generated title, publication, and in some
cases full text.
Some General Indexes:
- EBSCO Academic Search Premiere: a computer-only
magazine and journal index including full text of some articles.
- Reader's Guide to Periodical Literature : the
original index to magazines. Available in print back to 1900;
computer files usually go back to 1984, though some go all the
way back.
- Gale Infotrac : a computer-only magazine index,
usually covering 1979-; generally includes full text of SOME
articles; specialized indexes (like health) may be included.
Some Subject Indexes:
- Social Sciences Index: by the same people who do
Reader's Guide; computer files usually back to 1984.
- Historical Abstracts: indexes scholarly history
journals. Very dense. Theoretically only covers articles
addressing time periods after 1450, but some pre-1450 content
sneaks in. Limit by subject era. Subscription only.
- Anthropological Index : indexes periodicals on
anthropology (including archaelogy) online via the Royal
Anthropological Institute, UK: https://aio.therai.org.uk/
- Two very scholarly medieval indexes are International
Medieval Bibliography Online and ITER: Gateway to
the Middle Ages and Renaissance. These are worth checking
into if you run across them, but they are not easy to use.
- AATA Online: Abstracts of International Conservation
Literature (formerly Archaeology and Architecture
Technical Abstracts) free online from the Getty Museum: http://aata.getty.edu/Home/
- Feminae: Medieval Women and Gender Index free
online at: https://inpress.lib.uiowa.edu/feminae/default.aspx
There is a listing of free indexes on the Web called "There is
such a thing as a free lunch: freely accessible databases for the
public" at http://www.istl.org/01-winter/internet.html
. However, it focuses mostly on Science and Technology
databases. Many state library networks and local
libraries offer some free online access subscription databases for
local library card holders. See your local library-- you may well
need a library card number to use the databases. (Ohio,
Pennsylvania, and New Jersey have such programs.)
Citation indexes: backwards bibliographies--
listings of which articles are cited in other articles'
bibliographies. The Web of Science service is the most famous, but
you can use "Cited by" in Google Scholar as an alternative. There
is a significant learning curve to use them, but the effort is
worth it.
Google Scholar includes some citation indexing also. There is an
article on other citation/cited resources available here: http://www.lehigh.edu/library/guides/Citing/citations.html
Google Scholar
Google Scholar ( scholar.google.com
) is a metaindex to scholarly materials on the web, including
electronic journal article services, free indexes such as PubMed,
online e-texts of scholarly works (articles, books, theses),
scholarly institutional repositories, and proceedings, as well as
Google Books.. Google Scholar does not cover all scholarly works,
or even all article services ; the article services it indexes
often do not provide free etexts, but will sell you copies. It
does, however, include a Cited references function.
Catalog: the online database of a library's
book and journal titles. Many libraries have their catalog
available via the web. Try LibDex: http://www.libdex.com/ to
find library catalogs. Academic libraries are now supplementing
their catalogs with Discovery Services which provide a
single search box on the library's website searching the books and
journal articles the library has access to. Many discovery
services can be searched remotely, though you will not be able to
access the full text without an account for that library.
Union Catalog : A catalog of multiple
libraries' holdings. These used to be in print, but are now mostly
online. County library systems, state library systems, and
interlibrary loan groups have them. The most famous is Worldcat
from OCLC (see above). You may want to check out the Library of
Congress catalog, which is not really a union catalog: http://catalog.loc.gov .
Check your state or regional library's website to see if they have
a state or regionwide union catalog and if you can search it
directly. (These state/region catalogs often include the holdings
of school libraries and smaller public libraries)
OpenWorldcat
Open Worldcat is a program that makes library item records from
OCLC's Worldcat catalog available in search engines such as Yahoo
and Google. You'll recognize them by the 'Find in a Library' at the
beginning of the item title. Clicking on the link gives you basic
information about the book, and the opportunity to look for OCLC
libraries near your zip code that have the book. If you want to
search only Worldcat records, go to http://www.worldcat.org/ Be
aware that not all libraries are involved in Worldcat, and even if
their information is in Worldcat, their holdings may not
display in OpenWorldcat, and your local public library specifically
may not be in there-- so be sure to check public library catalogs
anyway.
Bibliographies : lists of books and articles on a
specific subject. Many libraries will have bibliographies in their
reference section that will help you find older books and articles.
Also, when you search the web, look for bibliographies on your
subject.
Techniques of searching
First, write down what you want to know. List all the keywords that
you can think of related to the topic. Then think about what kind of
book (history, how-to, description, encyclopedia, dictionary) might
have the information you want. Then start searching. First collect
background material from reference books. Then use catalogs and
indexes (and browsing) to build a list of materials to consult.
Natural Language Searching and Relevance Ranking
This is the kind of searching we are used to in Google and other web
search engines. No special terminology is needed, but the computer
guesses which keywords you input might be the most important, and
ranks your results accordingly. This puts you at the mercy of the
computer. Engines such as Google and Bing also use your previous
searches to tailor your results-- to avoid this, use a
'non-tracking' web search engine such as DuckDuckGo, or try
searching in Private or Incognito mode on your browser.
Tips:
- Put phrases in quotations: "viking apron dress"
- use special limiters such as site: or link:
- To avoid items that reference a specific term or are on a
specific site, use the minus sign: -site:pinterest.com
Subject headings
Most indexes and catalogs let you search by subject. It's important
to know what vocabulary to use. For library catalogs, take a look at
the Library of Congress Subject Headings. You should also make a
note of the subject headings (and see: and see also: references) in
the indexes you are using. The principle of specificity states that
a book or article is categorized under the most specific subject
term that fits, so you may have to search a bit.
Many catalogs (and indexes) will let you both keyword search (search
by terms that can be in the subject, title, or notes, including any
tables of contents that might be included) and also browse by
subject heading. If you pull up an entry for an interesting book and
see that the subject headings are hyperlinked, try clicking on them
to see if there are other books under that subject. Such links,
however, mostly only link to the exact subject heading, so you can
also try typing (or cut and pasting) the subject heading into the
Subject Browse.
Other kinds of searches
Library catalogs, indexes and other searching tools generally will
also allow you to searh by Author name and Title; most will also let
you limit your search by date, language, publisher, and type.
Searching by author and/or title is good for what librarians call
'known item' searching: looking for something you know exists. If
you are looking for a specific book, it may be worth your while to
search by the ISBN (International Standard Book Number) but remember
that different editions of a book will have different ISBN numbers!
You can also use author searches to look for related works, in
library catalogs or in journal indexes.
Boolean operators
Library databases (library catalogs, journal indexes) use Boolean
operators, such as AND, OR, and NOT, to combine terms.
- AND gives you all the items with both the first term AND the
second term
- OR gives you all the items with either the first term OR the
second term.
- NOT gives you the items with the first term but NOT the
second term
Some systems will automatically compensate for multiple
spellings; others will not. Look at the database's HELP to find
out what "truncation" operator they use (* and $ are common).
Truncation allows you to retrieve all words beginning with a
certain string (shoe* might get you shoes, shoemaker, etc.)
Pearl Growing-- a search strategy
Find one or two items that are what you are looking for. Go to the
indexes, the catalogs, and look up those items, then use their
entries to look for more like them: use the subject headings, the
author names, publishers, etc. Use bibliographies and citation
indexes; look for items under the same subject headings and by the
same authors. Most modern catalogs and indexes will actually make
subject headings, author names, etc. into hyperlinks you can click
to search for more items with those characteristics.
Types of sources
Dividing sources into primary/secondary/tertiary is a vexed
question. Different fields do this different ways. Be aware that
some fields are more stringent on this than others: some people
consider a painting a primary source, others don't. This is one
classification:
- Primary Sources are documents written at
the time, artifacts, manuals, etc. Some people do not believe
translations, photographs, or reproductions are primary sources;
some do. Documents written in period aren't always primary
sources, if the writer didn't actually witness what he or she is
describing.
- Secondary Sources describe or give
information from primary sources. Review articles, annotated
bibliographies, books like the London Excavations series, that
describe multiple items.
- Tertiary Sources : summarize, describe,
explain. Don't always pinpoint sources of each piece of
information. For instance, Complete Anachronist ; Smithsonian
articles.
Be aware that depending on what you want to know and what stage you
are in your research, primary sources may not be the best place
to begin. Tertiary sources can give you an overview of the
subject, and secondary sources can compare and contrast materials
that you might not otherwise know of, or summarize for you
information that you don't have the resources to collect yourself,
from inventories, records, remote locations, etc.
And sources from period, even primary sources, can be misleading or
biased. It's a good idea to consider the reliability of a source
more heavily than its type.
Is it a good source?
To analyze the reliability of a source: look for a bibliography
; check the credentials of the author
and publisher; check for obvious biases (does
the author have an axe to grind?); consider the audience
the book is written for. If possible, check out the items on the
bibliography-- are they primary sources? Are they academic
publications? Look for qualifying statements
instead of absolutes.
Once you've considered these issues, start fact-checking by "reading
laterally"-- looking for other sources on the same topic and
checking to see if they agree on facts. More information on Reading
Laterally can be found in Michael Caulfield's Web Literacy for
Student Fact-Checkers. https://webliteracy.pressbooks.com/
In general, analyze print and Web sources the same way. . Note that
even primary sources can be unreliable , if they are biased or
discussing something the author never saw, or if the author has a
reason to bend the facts.
Copyright & Plagiarism
Anything put in fixed form is copyrighted to the author (or whoever
buys the copyright from the author). That means that the author, or
the owner of the copyright, has the right to determine who can
distribute the work, within certain 'fair use' limits. You should
not copy and distribute other people's materials without permission.
That includes written work, sound recordings, video, and material on
the web! Copyright persists for up to 70 years after the
death of the author, depending on when the material was
created; if it was 'work made for hire' for a company, copyright
persists 95 or 120 years from creation. There are specific 'fair
use' ('fair dealing' in Canada) provisions to the copyright law that
allow for certain limited kinds of copying for research and
education (see the Stanford U Copyright and Fair Use site: https://fairuse.stanford.edu/
or the Copyright Office's web page: http://www.copyright.gov),
but you need the copyright owner's permission to copy significant
portions of a work or to reprint something. Looking for
something you can reproduce freely? Check out items that are in the
Public Domain (copyright expired) or are published under Creative
Commons licenses
(https://creativecommons.org/)
Plagiarism is reproducing or using someone else's work without
attributing it. Even if you only use a small portion-- a
sentence or two-- or just use someone's ideas, if you don't give
them credit, you are plagiarizing from their work. It is NEVER ok to
plagiarize anyone's work-- that is theft! A good source
explaining plagiarism and copyright, and how to avoid plagiarizing,
is Synthesis: Using the Work of Others, at the
University of Maine: http://plagiarism.umf.maine.edu/
Internet use:
"If the Net *is* a library, then it's adding a new wing today
(overnight), while removing another; and all the books at
the Reserve Desk are being moved to a new location; the online
catalog is being augmented by three new tools, (one of which
is free, one of which was written by the new person in Dept. A);
the entire phono disk collection just disappeared; any
number of users can simultaneously check out the latest
issue of the Journal of Obscure Chemistry; the Reference
department works at home now, and we just discovered 10,000
new books in a part of the library that we swear wasn't there
yesterday. And tomorrow will be different..."
--
Rick Gates
You'll notice that as you use the web you find a lot of beginner
stuff, very tertiary sources, some primary sources- some actually
only 'primary' to the sentimental 19th century--, and a lot of
junk. You'll also find online scholarship, often put online by
grant-funded projects, tenured professors, or "open access" journals
and institutional repositories. The trick is telling the difference.
ALA's Reference and User Services division, History Section, has a
nice resource on "Primary Sources on the Web: Finding, Evaluating,
Using"
http://www.ala.org/rusa/sections/history/resources/primarysources
Specifically for SCAdians, Karen Larsdatter wrote an article on
"Using the Internet for Research & Documentation" in Tournaments
Illuminated #145 (Winter 2003):
http://www.geocities.com/karen_larsdatter/using_the_internet.htm
This article includes both links to good sources and citation styles
for online sources. It's dated now, but the advice is worth looking
at.
"And though it may sound like heresy coming from someone who
lives and breathes web search, sometimes your best bet for finding
information is to log off and take a trip to your local library.
Libraries have tons of resources that aren't available on the Web.
And librarians are trained experts who are usually more than
willing to help you find what you're looking for. When you're
getting nowhere on the Web, take advantage of these (usually very
nice) 'human search engines.'"
-- Chris Sherman, "Seven Stupid Searching Mistakes, Concluded".
SearchEngine Watch, 28 March 2002:
http://www.searchenginewatch.com/searchday/article.php/2159571
Citing What You Find
Including a complete citation for sources not only helps other
people find the material you found-- but helps you get back to those
sources later.
The three main citation formats are University of Chicago (the
Turabian term paper manual is a variant of this), American
Psychological Association, and Modern Language Association. There
are all kinds of special rules in their handbooks for how to cite
material- most libraries will have the handbooks for you to check,
and there are a number of websites that describe the different
citation formats-- many librarians like the Purdue Owl online
writing resources: https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/research_and_citation/resources.html
(note: the automatic citation tools on these pages come from the
Citation Machine and are not high quality).
There are some online Citation Manager tools that help you keep
track of material you've located and create bibliographies for your
work.
- Zotero-- a free, open source citation manager: http://zotero.org and ZoteroBib,
a simple bibliography generator http://zbib.org
- Endnoteweb-- Sample version, online, of the most famous
citation manager (Endnote)
- RefWorks: a subscription based tool, usually available through
college & university subscriptions
- Citation Machine: a free service from Chegg for generating
citations (lots of ads, somewhat unreliable)
- EasyBib: a free citation service from Chegg for K-12
students-- even more ads
- NoodleTools: a subscription service for K-12 students
Many search engines and databases will let you automatically
generate a citation for the record you are looking at-- look for
"Cite" or "Citation" options on the page.
In general, it's less important what format you use than that you
include the information needed to find the item again.
What should go into a citation:
Journal/Magazine article:
- Author of the article
- Title of the article
- Title of the Journal/Magazine
- Volume and Issue
- Date of publication
- Page numbers
|
Book:
- Author(s) or editor(s)
- Book Title
- edition and/or volumes, if any
- Place of Publication
- Publisher name
- Date of Publication
|
Web site:
- Author, if any
- Title of the article
- Title of the site if it is part of a bigger site
- Sponsor of the site if known
- Date viewed
- URL (web page address)
|
Article in an edited book
- Author of the article
- Title of the article
- Title of the book
- Editor of the book
- Place of Publication
- Publisher name
- Date of Publication
- Page numbers
|
Other sites to check out:
"I have always maintained that librarians are the ultimate
share-your-toys people, and that the worst punishment you could
inflict on any of us is to offer to show us an incredibly useful
free resource but only if we swear not to tell another living
soul about it." -- Marylaine Block, Ex Libris
Here are a few sites that cover Research and Documentation for
the SCA:
And other general sites:
Glossary of Abbreviations:
- CIP : Cataloging In Publication- the Library
of Congress constructs basic library catalog records for books
submitted to the CIP program; these generally appear in the
front of the book.
- ERIC : a database indexing articles on
education
- ibid : 'in the same place;' used in
bibliographies to indicate that the entry is by the same author
or from the same publication as the publication cited just
before it.
- ILL : Interlibrary Loan- how libraries
borrow books from other libraries for their patrons to use.
- ISBN : International Standard Book Number- a
unique number assigned to each edition of a book.
- ISSN : International Standard Serial Number-
a unique number assigned to each journal and magazine title
- MARC : Machine Readable Cataloging- MARC
format displays parts of a library catalog record with the
numbers that indicate what parts they are.
- OCLC : OCLC is a library cooperative that
has ILL, searching, cataloging, cooperative database purchasing
and other services. The term 'OCLC' is also used to refer to
OCLC's ILL and cataloging databases.
- RLIN : RLIN was a library cooperative like
OCLC; it's now part of OCLC.